[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":1139},["ShallowReactive",2],{"navigation":3,"\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc8":355,"\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc8-surround":1134},[4,252,348],{"title":5,"path":6,"stem":7,"children":8,"icon":11},"Active Directory","\u002Factive-directory","1.active-directory\u002F1.index",[9,12,48,58,93,163,203,232],{"title":10,"path":6,"stem":7,"icon":11},"Übersicht","i-lucide-network",{"title":13,"path":14,"stem":15,"children":16,"page":47},"Privileged Accounts","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts",[17,22,27,32,37,42],{"title":18,"path":19,"stem":20,"icon":21},"Protected Users","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Fprotected-users","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F2.protected-users","i-lucide-shield-user",{"title":23,"path":24,"stem":25,"icon":26},"Not Delegated","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Faccount-not-delegated","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F3.account-not-delegated","i-lucide-user-lock",{"title":28,"path":29,"stem":30,"icon":31},"gMSA","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Fgmsa","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F4.gmsa","i-lucide-server-cog",{"title":33,"path":34,"stem":35,"icon":36},"Tier-0-Gruppen","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Fprivileged-groups","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F5.privileged-groups","i-lucide-crown",{"title":38,"path":39,"stem":40,"icon":41},"Operator-Gruppen","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Foperator-groups","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F6.operator-groups","i-lucide-user-minus",{"title":43,"path":44,"stem":45,"icon":46},"Built-in Administrator","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Fbuiltin-administrator","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F7.builtin-administrator","i-lucide-siren",false,{"title":49,"path":50,"stem":51,"children":52,"page":47},"Trusts","\u002Factive-directory\u002Ftrusts","1.active-directory\u002F3.trusts",[53],{"title":54,"path":55,"stem":56,"icon":57},"Trust-Härtung","\u002Factive-directory\u002Ftrusts\u002Ftrust-hardening","1.active-directory\u002F3.trusts\u002F2.trust-hardening","i-lucide-handshake",{"title":59,"path":60,"stem":61,"children":62,"page":47},"Domain Controllers","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers",[63,68,73,78,83,88],{"title":64,"path":65,"stem":66,"icon":67},"NTLMv1","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fntlmv1","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F2.ntlmv1","i-lucide-shield-ban",{"title":69,"path":70,"stem":71,"icon":72},"LDAP","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fldap","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F3.ldap","i-lucide-book-lock",{"title":74,"path":75,"stem":76,"icon":77},"NTLM-Einschränkungen","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fntlm-restrictions","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F4.ntlm-restrictions","i-lucide-shield-minus",{"title":79,"path":80,"stem":81,"icon":82},"SYSVOL-Replikation (FRS)","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fsysvol-frs","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F5.sysvol-frs","i-lucide-folder-sync",{"title":84,"path":85,"stem":86,"icon":87},"DNS","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fdns","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F6.dns","i-lucide-globe-lock",{"title":89,"path":90,"stem":91,"icon":92},"DCSync-Rechte","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fdcsync","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F7.dcsync","i-lucide-database-zap",{"title":94,"path":95,"stem":96,"children":97,"page":47},"Certificates (AD CS)","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates",[98,103,108,113,118,123,128,133,138,143,148,153,158],{"title":99,"path":100,"stem":101,"icon":102},"ESC1","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc1","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F01.esc1","i-lucide-user-pen",{"title":104,"path":105,"stem":106,"icon":107},"ESC2","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc2","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F02.esc2","i-lucide-asterisk",{"title":109,"path":110,"stem":111,"icon":112},"ESC3","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc3","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F03.esc3","i-lucide-stamp",{"title":114,"path":115,"stem":116,"icon":117},"ESC4","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc4","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F04.esc4","i-lucide-file-pen-line",{"title":119,"path":120,"stem":121,"icon":122},"ESC5","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc5","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F05.esc5","i-lucide-folder-key",{"title":124,"path":125,"stem":126,"icon":127},"ESC6","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc6","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F06.esc6","i-lucide-flag",{"title":129,"path":130,"stem":131,"icon":132},"ESC7","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc7","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F07.esc7","i-lucide-user-cog",{"title":134,"path":135,"stem":136,"icon":137},"ESC8","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc8","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F08.esc8","i-lucide-globe",{"title":139,"path":140,"stem":141,"icon":142},"ESC9","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc9","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F09.esc9","i-lucide-shield-off",{"title":144,"path":145,"stem":146,"icon":147},"ESC10","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc10","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F10.esc10","i-lucide-unlink",{"title":149,"path":150,"stem":151,"icon":152},"ESC11","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc11","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F11.esc11","i-lucide-cable",{"title":154,"path":155,"stem":156,"icon":157},"ESC12","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc12","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F12.esc12","i-lucide-usb",{"title":159,"path":160,"stem":161,"icon":162},"ESC13","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc13","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F13.esc13","i-lucide-tags",{"title":164,"path":165,"stem":166,"children":167,"page":47},"Kerberos","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos",[168,173,178,183,188,193,198],{"title":169,"path":170,"stem":171,"icon":172},"Kerberoasting","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Fkerberoasting","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F2.kerberoasting","i-lucide-ticket",{"title":174,"path":175,"stem":176,"icon":177},"AS-REP Roasting","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Fasrep-roasting","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F3.asrep-roasting","i-lucide-ticket-x",{"title":179,"path":180,"stem":181,"icon":182},"Unconstrained Delegation","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Funconstrained-delegation","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F4.unconstrained-delegation","i-lucide-forward",{"title":184,"path":185,"stem":186,"icon":187},"Constrained Delegation","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Fconstrained-delegation","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F5.constrained-delegation","i-lucide-route",{"title":189,"path":190,"stem":191,"icon":192},"MachineAccountQuota","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Fmachine-account-quota","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F6.machine-account-quota","i-lucide-monitor-x",{"title":194,"path":195,"stem":196,"icon":197},"RC4 & DES","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Frc4-des","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F7.rc4-des","i-lucide-lock-keyhole-open",{"title":199,"path":200,"stem":201,"icon":202},"KRBTGT","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Fkrbtgt","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F8.krbtgt","i-lucide-rotate-ccw-key",{"title":204,"path":205,"stem":206,"children":207,"page":47},"Permissions","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions",[208,213,217,222,227],{"title":209,"path":210,"stem":211,"icon":212},"AdminSDHolder","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions\u002Fadminsdholder","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions\u002F2.adminsdholder","i-lucide-copy-check",{"title":214,"path":215,"stem":216,"icon":36},"Objekt-Owner","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions\u002Fobject-owners","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions\u002F3.object-owners",{"title":218,"path":219,"stem":220,"icon":221},"Shadow Credentials","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions\u002Fshadow-credentials","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions\u002F4.shadow-credentials","i-lucide-fingerprint",{"title":223,"path":224,"stem":225,"icon":226},"GPO-Rechte","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions\u002Fgpo-permissions","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions\u002F5.gpo-permissions","i-lucide-file-cog",{"title":228,"path":229,"stem":230,"icon":231},"dSHeuristics","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions\u002Fdsheuristics","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions\u002F6.dsheuristics","i-lucide-sliders-horizontal",{"title":233,"path":234,"stem":235,"children":236,"page":47},"Passwords","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpasswords","1.active-directory\u002F8.passwords",[237,242,247],{"title":238,"path":239,"stem":240,"icon":241},"Passwort-Richtlinie","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpasswords\u002Fpassword-policy","1.active-directory\u002F8.passwords\u002F2.password-policy","i-lucide-rectangle-ellipsis",{"title":243,"path":244,"stem":245,"icon":246},"Passwort-Flags","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpasswords\u002Fpassword-flags","1.active-directory\u002F8.passwords\u002F3.password-flags","i-lucide-key-square",{"title":248,"path":249,"stem":250,"icon":251},"Klartext-Passwörter","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpasswords\u002Fcleartext-passwords","1.active-directory\u002F8.passwords\u002F4.cleartext-passwords","i-lucide-scan-eye",{"title":253,"path":254,"stem":255,"children":256,"icon":258},"Infrastruktur","\u002Finfrastruktur","2.infrastruktur\u002F1.index",[257,259,270,301,327],{"title":10,"path":254,"stem":255,"icon":258},"i-lucide-server",{"title":260,"icon":261,"path":262,"stem":263,"children":264,"page":47},"TLS & SSL","i-lucide-lock","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Ftls-ssl","2.infrastruktur\u002F2.tls-ssl",[265],{"title":266,"path":267,"stem":268,"icon":269},"Client-Renegotiation","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Ftls-ssl\u002Fclient-renegotiation","2.infrastruktur\u002F2.tls-ssl\u002F1.client-renegotiation","i-lucide-refresh-cw",{"title":271,"icon":272,"path":273,"stem":274,"children":275,"page":47},"Windows","i-simple-icons-windows","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows",[276,281,286,291,296],{"title":277,"path":278,"stem":279,"icon":280},"AlwaysInstallElevated","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows\u002Falwaysinstallelevated","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows\u002F2.alwaysinstallelevated","i-lucide-package",{"title":282,"path":283,"stem":284,"icon":285},"SMB","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows\u002Fsmb","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows\u002F3.smb","i-lucide-folder-lock",{"title":287,"path":288,"stem":289,"icon":290},"WSUS","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows\u002Fwsus","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows\u002F4.wsus","i-lucide-cloud-download",{"title":292,"path":293,"stem":294,"icon":295},"LAPS","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows\u002Flaps","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows\u002F5.laps","i-lucide-user-key",{"title":297,"path":298,"stem":299,"icon":300},"Print Spooler","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows\u002Fprint-spooler","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows\u002F6.print-spooler","i-lucide-printer-x",{"title":302,"icon":303,"path":304,"stem":305,"children":306,"page":47},"Email Security","i-lucide-mail","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Femail-security","2.infrastruktur\u002F5.email-security",[307,312,317,322],{"title":308,"path":309,"stem":310,"icon":311},"SPF","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Femail-security\u002Fspf","2.infrastruktur\u002F5.email-security\u002F2.spf","i-lucide-mail-check",{"title":313,"path":314,"stem":315,"icon":316},"DKIM","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Femail-security\u002Fdkim","2.infrastruktur\u002F5.email-security\u002F3.dkim","i-lucide-mail-badge",{"title":318,"path":319,"stem":320,"icon":321},"DMARC","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Femail-security\u002Fdmarc","2.infrastruktur\u002F5.email-security\u002F4.dmarc","i-lucide-shield-check",{"title":323,"path":324,"stem":325,"icon":326},"DNSSEC","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Femail-security\u002Fdnssec","2.infrastruktur\u002F5.email-security\u002F5.dnssec","i-lucide-key-round",{"title":328,"icon":329,"path":330,"stem":331,"children":332,"page":47},"Name Resolution","i-lucide-radio-tower","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fname-resolution","2.infrastruktur\u002F7.name-resolution",[333,338,343],{"title":334,"path":335,"stem":336,"icon":337},"LLMNR","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fname-resolution\u002Fllmnr","2.infrastruktur\u002F7.name-resolution\u002F2.llmnr","i-lucide-radio",{"title":339,"path":340,"stem":341,"icon":342},"NetBIOS","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fname-resolution\u002Fnetbios","2.infrastruktur\u002F7.name-resolution\u002F3.netbios","i-lucide-megaphone-off",{"title":344,"path":345,"stem":346,"icon":347},"mDNS","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fname-resolution\u002Fmdns","2.infrastruktur\u002F7.name-resolution\u002F4.mdns","i-lucide-wifi-off",{"title":349,"path":350,"stem":351,"children":352,"icon":354},"Cloud & SaaS","\u002Fcloud-saas","3.cloud-saas\u002F1.index",[353],{"title":10,"path":350,"stem":351,"icon":354},"i-lucide-cloud",{"id":356,"title":134,"body":357,"description":1127,"extension":1128,"links":1129,"meta":1130,"navigation":1131,"path":135,"seo":1132,"stem":136,"__hash__":1133},"docs\u002F1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F08.esc8.md",{"type":358,"value":359,"toc":1115},"minimark",[360,365,381,385,388,401,404,408,414,420,426,430,435,438,455,458,510,525,532,535,600,607,613,616,622,625,634,645,730,741,768,771,775,782,791,832,836,839,854,863,867,870,895,898,904,914,971,985,991,994,1017,1022,1026,1029,1050,1104,1111],[361,362,364],"h2",{"id":363},"verstehen","Verstehen",[366,367,368,369,373,374,376,377,380],"p",{},"AD CS bringt optionale Web-Dienste mit, über die Clients Zertifikate per HTTP beantragen: die Web-Enrollment-Oberfläche unter ",[370,371,372],"code",{},"\u002Fcertsrv"," und den Certificate Enrollment Web Service (CES). Beide laufen im IIS und authentifizieren per Windows-Anmeldung, also Kerberos oder NTLM. NTLM-Anmeldungen lassen sich an einen anderen Server weiterleiten (Relay), solange dieser sie nicht an die TLS-Verbindung bindet. Genau diese Bindung – Extended Protection for Authentication (EPA) – wird auf diesen Endpunkten oft nicht erzwungen, und ",[370,375,372],{}," ist häufig sogar über unverschlüsseltes HTTP erreichbar. ESC8 beschreibt diese Lücke; breit bekannt wurde sie 2021 zusammen mit PetitPotam. Die Rollendienste werden gern „für alle Fälle\" mitinstalliert und danach nie genutzt. Das Gegenstück über RPC ist ",[378,379,149],"a",{"href":150},".",[361,382,384],{"id":383},"einordnen","Einordnen",[366,386,387],{},"Ohne die Korrektur kann ein Angreifer im Netz die NTLM-Anmeldung eines fremden Kontos an die CA weiterleiten und sich in dessen Namen ein Zertifikat ausstellen lassen.",[389,390,391,398],"ul",{},[392,393,394,395,397],"li",{},"Er bringt einen Domain Controller dazu, sich bei ihm anzumelden (Coercion), leitet die Anmeldung an ",[370,396,372],{}," weiter und erhält ein Zertifikat für das Computerkonto des DC – damit lassen sich die Passwort-Hashes der gesamten Domäne abrufen",[392,399,400],{},"Er leitet Anmeldungen weiter, die er per Spoofing im lokalen Netz einsammelt, und beantragt Zertifikate im Namen der betroffenen Benutzer und Server",[366,402,403],{},"Der Angreifer braucht dafür nur einen Platz im Netz, keine Adminrechte. HTTPS allein schützt nicht: Ohne EPA lässt sich eine Anmeldung auch an einen HTTPS-Endpunkt weiterleiten. Wirksam sind EPA mit erzwungenem TLS, der Verzicht auf NTLM – oder gar kein Web-Dienst. Coercion-Wege zu schließen und NTLM insgesamt zurückzudrängen senkt das Risiko zusätzlich, ersetzt die Härtung der Endpunkte aber nicht.",[361,405,407],{"id":406},"vorbereiten","Vorbereiten",[366,409,410,411,413],{},"Betroffen ist alles, was Zertifikate über HTTP beantragt: Admins, die ",[370,412,372],{}," im Browser nutzen, Geräte und Skripte außerhalb der Domäne, Clients, die per CES enrollen – etwa aus anderen Forests. Domänen-Clients mit Autoenrollment nutzen RPC\u002FDCOM und merken von der Änderung nichts. Mit EPA auf „Required\" scheitern Clients, die kein Channel Binding unterstützen.",[415,416,417],"warning",{},[366,418,419],{},"Größtes Risiko: Zwischen Client und IIS sitzt ein Load Balancer oder Reverse Proxy, der TLS terminiert. Mit EPA auf „Required\" schlägt dann jede Anmeldung fehl, weil das Channel Binding nicht mehr zur Verbindung passt. Prüf den Pfad vorher und teste mit einem Client, bevor du produktiv umstellst.",[421,422,423],"tip",{},[366,424,425],{},"Frag zuerst, ob die Web-Dienste überhaupt gebraucht werden. In den meisten Umgebungen läuft alles über Autoenrollment und die MMC – dann ist Deinstallieren die einfachste und sicherste Lösung (Schritt 3).",[361,427,429],{"id":428},"beheben","Beheben",[431,432,434],"h3",{"id":433},"_1-aktuellen-zustand-prüfen","1. Aktuellen Zustand prüfen",[366,436,437],{},"Auf jedem CA-Server prüfen, welche Web-Rollendienste installiert sind:",[439,440,446],"pre",{"className":441,"code":442,"filename":443,"language":444,"meta":445,"style":445},"language-powershell shiki shiki-themes material-theme-lighter material-theme material-theme-palenight","Get-WindowsFeature ADCS-Web-Enrollment, ADCS-Enroll-Web-Svc, ADCS-Enroll-Web-Pol | Select-Object Name, InstallState\n","PowerShell","powershell","",[370,447,448],{"__ignoreMap":445},[449,450,453],"span",{"class":451,"line":452},"line",1,[449,454,442],{},[366,456,457],{},"Aus dem Netz prüfen, was der Endpunkt anbietet:",[439,459,464],{"className":460,"code":461,"filename":462,"language":463,"meta":445,"style":445},"language-bash shiki shiki-themes material-theme-lighter material-theme material-theme-palenight","curl -s -o \u002Fdev\u002Fnull -D - http:\u002F\u002Fsrv01.contoso.local\u002Fcertsrv\u002F\ncurl -sk -o \u002Fdev\u002Fnull -D - https:\u002F\u002Fsrv01.contoso.local\u002Fcertsrv\u002F\n","Terminal","bash",[370,465,466,491],{"__ignoreMap":445},[449,467,468,472,476,479,482,485,488],{"class":451,"line":452},[449,469,471],{"class":470},"sBMFI","curl",[449,473,475],{"class":474},"sfazB"," -s",[449,477,478],{"class":474}," -o",[449,480,481],{"class":474}," \u002Fdev\u002Fnull",[449,483,484],{"class":474}," -D",[449,486,487],{"class":474}," -",[449,489,490],{"class":474}," http:\u002F\u002Fsrv01.contoso.local\u002Fcertsrv\u002F\n",[449,492,494,496,499,501,503,505,507],{"class":451,"line":493},2,[449,495,471],{"class":470},[449,497,498],{"class":474}," -sk",[449,500,478],{"class":474},[449,502,481],{"class":474},[449,504,484],{"class":474},[449,506,487],{"class":474},[449,508,509],{"class":474}," https:\u002F\u002Fsrv01.contoso.local\u002Fcertsrv\u002F\n",[439,511,513],{"className":441,"code":512,"filename":443,"language":444,"meta":445,"style":445},"curl.exe -s -o NUL -D - http:\u002F\u002Fsrv01.contoso.local\u002Fcertsrv\u002F\ncurl.exe -sk -o NUL -D - https:\u002F\u002Fsrv01.contoso.local\u002Fcertsrv\u002F\n",[370,514,515,520],{"__ignoreMap":445},[449,516,517],{"class":451,"line":452},[449,518,519],{},"curl.exe -s -o NUL -D - http:\u002F\u002Fsrv01.contoso.local\u002Fcertsrv\u002F\n",[449,521,522],{"class":451,"line":493},[449,523,524],{},"curl.exe -sk -o NUL -D - https:\u002F\u002Fsrv01.contoso.local\u002Fcertsrv\u002F\n",[366,526,527],{},[528,529],"img",{"alt":530,"src":531},"curl-Antwort von \u002Fcertsrv über HTTP mit Status 401 und den Headern WWW-Authenticate Negotiate und NTLM","\u002Fimg\u002Factive-directory\u002Fesc8-curl.png",[366,533,534],{},"Mögliche Ergebnisse:",[536,537,538,551],"table",{},[539,540,541],"thead",{},[542,543,544,548],"tr",{},[545,546,547],"th",{},"Antwort",[545,549,550],{},"Bedeutung",[552,553,554,574,589],"tbody",{},[542,555,556,571],{},[557,558,559,562,563,566,567,570],"td",{},[370,560,561],{},"401"," mit ",[370,564,565],{},"WWW-Authenticate: NTLM"," oder ",[370,568,569],{},"Negotiate"," über HTTP",[557,572,573],{},"verwundbar – NTLM ohne TLS",[542,575,576,586],{},[557,577,578,562,580,566,583,585],{},[370,579,561],{},[370,581,582],{},"NTLM",[370,584,569],{}," nur über HTTPS",[557,587,588],{},"verwundbar, solange EPA nicht auf „Required\" steht",[542,590,591,597],{},[557,592,593,594],{},"keine Verbindung oder ",[370,595,596],{},"404",[557,598,599],{},"Web Enrollment nicht vorhanden",[366,601,602,603,606],{},"Wie EPA und TLS eingestellt sind, zeigt der IIS-Manager (",[370,604,605],{},"inetmgr",") auf dem Server: „Sites\" → „Default Web Site\" → „CertSrv\" → „Authentication\". Ist „Windows Authentication\" aktiv und EPA nicht erzwungen, weist IIS unter „Alerts\" selbst auf Extended Protection hin:",[366,608,609],{},[528,610],{"alt":611,"src":612},"IIS-Manager, Seite „Authentication\" der Anwendung CertSrv mit aktiver Windows Authentication und dem Hinweis auf Extended Protection","\u002Fimg\u002Factive-directory\u002Fesc8-authentication.png",[366,614,615],{},"Den Wert zeigt „Windows Authentication\" → „Advanced Settings\" (Screenshot in Schritt 4). Ob HTTP erlaubt ist, steht unter „SSL Settings\" der Anwendung:",[366,617,618],{},[528,619],{"alt":620,"src":621},"IIS-Manager, Seite „SSL Settings\" der Anwendung CertSrv mit deaktivierter Option „Require SSL\"","\u002Fimg\u002Factive-directory\u002Fesc8-ssl-settings.png",[366,623,624],{},"Welche Bindungen die Site hat, zeigt:",[439,626,628],{"className":441,"code":627,"filename":443,"language":444,"meta":445,"style":445},"Get-WebBinding -Name 'Default Web Site'\n",[370,629,630],{"__ignoreMap":445},[449,631,632],{"class":451,"line":452},[449,633,627],{},[366,635,636,637,640,641,644],{},"Eine Zeile mit ",[370,638,639],{},"http"," und ",[370,642,643],{},"*:80:"," heißt, dass die Site auch unverschlüsselt erreichbar ist. Ohne „Require SSL\" läuft die Anmeldung dann über HTTP.",[536,646,647,659],{},[539,648,649],{},[542,650,651,654,657],{},[545,652,653],{},"Einstellung im IIS-Manager",[545,655,656],{},"Wert in der Konfiguration",[545,658,550],{},[552,660,661,678,691,704,717],{},[542,662,663,666,675],{},[557,664,665],{},"Extended Protection „Off\"",[557,667,668,671,672],{},[370,669,670],{},"tokenChecking"," fehlt oder ",[370,673,674],{},"None",[557,676,677],{},"kein EPA – verwundbar",[542,679,680,683,688],{},[557,681,682],{},"Extended Protection „Accept\"",[557,684,685],{},[370,686,687],{},"tokenChecking=\"Allow\"",[557,689,690],{},"EPA nur, wenn der Client es anbietet – Relay bleibt möglich",[542,692,693,696,701],{},[557,694,695],{},"Extended Protection „Required\"",[557,697,698],{},[370,699,700],{},"tokenChecking=\"Require\"",[557,702,703],{},"Zielzustand",[542,705,706,709,714],{},[557,707,708],{},"„Require SSL\" aus",[557,710,711],{},[370,712,713],{},"sslFlags=\"None\"",[557,715,716],{},"HTTP erlaubt – verwundbar",[542,718,719,722,727],{},[557,720,721],{},"„Require SSL\" an",[557,723,724],{},[370,725,726],{},"sslFlags=\"Ssl\"",[557,728,729],{},"nur HTTPS – Zielzustand",[366,731,732,733,736,737,740],{},"Für CES heißt die IIS-Anwendung nach dem Muster ",[370,734,735],{},"\u003CCA Name>_CES_Kerberos"," – prüf sie auf dieselbe Weise. Per Kommandozeile liest ",[370,738,739],{},"appcmd"," dieselben Werte aus:",[742,743,747],"collapsible",{"close-text":744,"name":745,"open-text":746},"Ausblenden:","appcmd-Abfrage","Anzeigen:",[439,748,750],{"className":441,"code":749,"filename":443,"language":444,"meta":445,"style":445},"$appcmd = \"$env:windir\\system32\\inetsrv\\appcmd.exe\"\n& $appcmd list config \"Default Web Site\u002FCertSrv\" -section:system.webServer\u002Fsecurity\u002Fauthentication\u002FwindowsAuthentication\n& $appcmd list config \"Default Web Site\u002FCertSrv\" -section:system.webServer\u002Fsecurity\u002Faccess\n",[370,751,752,757,762],{"__ignoreMap":445},[449,753,754],{"class":451,"line":452},[449,755,756],{},"$appcmd = \"$env:windir\\system32\\inetsrv\\appcmd.exe\"\n",[449,758,759],{"class":451,"line":493},[449,760,761],{},"& $appcmd list config \"Default Web Site\u002FCertSrv\" -section:system.webServer\u002Fsecurity\u002Fauthentication\u002FwindowsAuthentication\n",[449,763,765],{"class":451,"line":764},3,[449,766,767],{},"& $appcmd list config \"Default Web Site\u002FCertSrv\" -section:system.webServer\u002Fsecurity\u002Faccess\n",[366,769,770],{},"Nutzt du Microsoft Defender for Identity mit einem Sensor auf dem CA-Server, listet der Secure Score im Defender-Portal betroffene Endpunkte unter der Empfehlung „Edit insecure ADCS certificate enrollment IIS endpoints (ESC8)\".",[431,772,774],{"id":773},"_2-bedarf-klären","2. Bedarf klären",[366,776,777,778,781],{},"Ob jemand die Web-Oberfläche benutzt, zeigen die IIS-Logs. Zertifikatsanträge laufen über die Seite ",[370,779,780],{},"certfnsh.asp",":",[439,783,785],{"className":441,"code":784,"filename":443,"language":444,"meta":445,"style":445},"Select-String -Path C:\\inetpub\\logs\\LogFiles\\W3SVC1\\*.log -Pattern 'certfnsh.asp' | Select-Object -Last 20\n",[370,786,787],{"__ignoreMap":445},[449,788,789],{"class":451,"line":452},[449,790,784],{},[536,792,793,802],{},[539,794,795],{},[542,796,797,800],{},[545,798,799],{},"Ergebnis",[545,801,550],{},[552,803,804,812,824],{},[542,805,806,809],{},[557,807,808],{},"keine Treffer über mehrere Wochen",[557,810,811],{},"Web Enrollment wird nicht genutzt – entfernen (Schritt 3)",[542,813,814,817],{},[557,815,816],{},"Treffer von wenigen Admin-Arbeitsplätzen",[557,818,819,820,823],{},"Ablauf auf MMC oder ",[370,821,822],{},"certreq"," umstellen, dann entfernen",[542,825,826,829],{},[557,827,828],{},"Treffer von Geräten oder Skripten",[557,830,831],{},"Endpunkt bleibt vorerst – härten (Schritt 4)",[431,833,835],{"id":834},"_3-nicht-benötigte-web-dienste-entfernen","3. Nicht benötigte Web-Dienste entfernen",[366,837,838],{},"Auf dem CA-Server:",[439,840,842],{"className":441,"code":841,"filename":443,"language":444,"meta":445,"style":445},"Uninstall-AdcsWebEnrollment -Force\nUninstall-WindowsFeature ADCS-Web-Enrollment\n",[370,843,844,849],{"__ignoreMap":445},[449,845,846],{"class":451,"line":452},[449,847,848],{},"Uninstall-AdcsWebEnrollment -Force\n",[449,850,851],{"class":451,"line":493},[449,852,853],{},"Uninstall-WindowsFeature ADCS-Web-Enrollment\n",[366,855,856,857,640,860,380],{},"Die CA selbst läuft weiter, Autoenrollment und die MMC sind nicht betroffen. CES und den Certificate Enrollment Policy Web Service entfernst du entsprechend mit ",[370,858,859],{},"Uninstall-AdcsEnrollmentWebService",[370,861,862],{},"Uninstall-AdcsEnrollmentPolicyWebService",[431,864,866],{"id":865},"_4-verbleibende-endpunkte-härten","4. Verbleibende Endpunkte härten",[366,868,869],{},"Voraussetzung ist eine HTTPS-Bindung mit gültigem Server-Zertifikat auf der Site. Danach EPA erzwingen und HTTP abschalten:",[439,871,873],{"className":441,"code":872,"filename":443,"language":444,"meta":445,"style":445},"$appcmd = \"$env:windir\\system32\\inetsrv\\appcmd.exe\"\n& $appcmd set config \"Default Web Site\u002FCertSrv\" -section:system.webServer\u002Fsecurity\u002Fauthentication\u002FwindowsAuthentication \u002FextendedProtection.tokenChecking:\"Require\" \u002Fcommit:apphost\n& $appcmd set config \"Default Web Site\u002FCertSrv\" -section:system.webServer\u002Fsecurity\u002Faccess \u002FsslFlags:\"Ssl\" \u002Fcommit:apphost\niisreset \u002Frestart\n",[370,874,875,879,884,889],{"__ignoreMap":445},[449,876,877],{"class":451,"line":452},[449,878,756],{},[449,880,881],{"class":451,"line":493},[449,882,883],{},"& $appcmd set config \"Default Web Site\u002FCertSrv\" -section:system.webServer\u002Fsecurity\u002Fauthentication\u002FwindowsAuthentication \u002FextendedProtection.tokenChecking:\"Require\" \u002Fcommit:apphost\n",[449,885,886],{"class":451,"line":764},[449,887,888],{},"& $appcmd set config \"Default Web Site\u002FCertSrv\" -section:system.webServer\u002Fsecurity\u002Faccess \u002FsslFlags:\"Ssl\" \u002Fcommit:apphost\n",[449,890,892],{"class":451,"line":891},4,[449,893,894],{},"iisreset \u002Frestart\n",[366,896,897],{},"Im IIS-Manager liegen dieselben Einstellungen unter „Authentication\" → „Windows Authentication\" → „Advanced Settings\" → „Extended Protection: Required\" und unter „SSL Settings\" → „Require SSL\". Im Ausgangszustand steht Extended Protection auf „Off\":",[366,899,900],{},[528,901],{"alt":902,"src":903},"Dialog „Advanced Settings\" der Windows Authentication im IIS-Manager mit Extended Protection auf „Off\"","\u002Fimg\u002Factive-directory\u002Fesc8-extended-protection.png",[366,905,906,907,910,911,781],{},"Für CES verlangt Microsoft zusätzlich einen Eintrag in der ",[370,908,909],{},"web.config"," der Anwendung unter ",[370,912,913],{},"%windir%\\systemdata\\CES\\\u003CCA Name>_CES_Kerberos\\web.config",[439,915,919],{"className":916,"code":917,"filename":909,"language":918,"meta":445,"style":445},"language-xml shiki shiki-themes material-theme-lighter material-theme material-theme-palenight","\u003Cbinding name=\"TransportWithHeaderClientAuth\">\n  \u003Csecurity mode=\"Transport\">\n    \u003Ctransport clientCredentialType=\"Windows\">\n      \u003CextendedProtectionPolicy policyEnforcement=\"Always\" \u002F>\n    \u003C\u002Ftransport>\n    \u003Cmessage clientCredentialType=\"None\" establishSecurityContext=\"false\" negotiateServiceCredential=\"false\" \u002F>\n  \u003C\u002Fsecurity>\n  \u003CreaderQuotas maxStringContentLength=\"131072\" \u002F>\n\u003C\u002Fbinding>\n","xml",[370,920,921,926,931,936,941,947,953,959,965],{"__ignoreMap":445},[449,922,923],{"class":451,"line":452},[449,924,925],{},"\u003Cbinding name=\"TransportWithHeaderClientAuth\">\n",[449,927,928],{"class":451,"line":493},[449,929,930],{},"  \u003Csecurity mode=\"Transport\">\n",[449,932,933],{"class":451,"line":764},[449,934,935],{},"    \u003Ctransport clientCredentialType=\"Windows\">\n",[449,937,938],{"class":451,"line":891},[449,939,940],{},"      \u003CextendedProtectionPolicy policyEnforcement=\"Always\" \u002F>\n",[449,942,944],{"class":451,"line":943},5,[449,945,946],{},"    \u003C\u002Ftransport>\n",[449,948,950],{"class":451,"line":949},6,[449,951,952],{},"    \u003Cmessage clientCredentialType=\"None\" establishSecurityContext=\"false\" negotiateServiceCredential=\"false\" \u002F>\n",[449,954,956],{"class":451,"line":955},7,[449,957,958],{},"  \u003C\u002Fsecurity>\n",[449,960,962],{"class":451,"line":961},8,[449,963,964],{},"  \u003CreaderQuotas maxStringContentLength=\"131072\" \u002F>\n",[449,966,968],{"class":451,"line":967},9,[449,969,970],{},"\u003C\u002Fbinding>\n",[366,972,973,974,976,977,980,981,640,983,781],{},"Wer NTLM auf dem Endpunkt nicht braucht, schaltet es zusätzlich ab: im IIS-Manager unter „Authentication\" → „Windows Authentication\" → „Providers\" den Eintrag ",[370,975,582],{}," entfernen und ",[370,978,979],{},"Negotiate:Kerberos"," setzen. Im Standard stehen dort ",[370,982,569],{},[370,984,582],{},[366,986,987],{},[528,988],{"alt":989,"src":990},"Dialog „Providers\" der Windows Authentication im IIS-Manager mit den Einträgen Negotiate und NTLM","\u002Fimg\u002Factive-directory\u002Fesc8-providers.png",[366,992,993],{},"Als weitere Absicherung nennt Microsoft das Sperren eingehender NTLM-Anmeldungen auf den AD-CS-Servern:",[439,995,1000],{"className":996,"code":997,"filename":998,"language":999,"meta":445,"style":445},"language-ini shiki shiki-themes material-theme-lighter material-theme material-theme-palenight","Computer Configuration\\Windows Settings\\Security Settings\\Local Policies\\Security Options\n  Network security: Restrict NTLM: Incoming NTLM traffic\n    = Deny all domain accounts\n","GPO","ini",[370,1001,1002,1007,1012],{"__ignoreMap":445},[449,1003,1004],{"class":451,"line":452},[449,1005,1006],{},"Computer Configuration\\Windows Settings\\Security Settings\\Local Policies\\Security Options\n",[449,1008,1009],{"class":451,"line":493},[449,1010,1011],{},"  Network security: Restrict NTLM: Incoming NTLM traffic\n",[449,1013,1014],{"class":451,"line":764},[449,1015,1016],{},"    = Deny all domain accounts\n",[415,1018,1019],{},[366,1020,1021],{},"Die NTLM-Sperre trifft alle Dienste auf dem Server, nicht nur den IIS. Werte vorher das NTLM-Auditing aus, bevor du sie auf einem CA-Server setzt.",[431,1023,1025],{"id":1024},"_5-verifizieren","5. Verifizieren",[366,1027,1028],{},"Die Abfragen aus Schritt 1 wiederholen:",[439,1030,1032],{"className":460,"code":1031,"filename":462,"language":463,"meta":445,"style":445},"curl -s -o \u002Fdev\u002Fnull -D - http:\u002F\u002Fsrv01.contoso.local\u002Fcertsrv\u002F\n",[370,1033,1034],{"__ignoreMap":445},[449,1035,1036,1038,1040,1042,1044,1046,1048],{"class":451,"line":452},[449,1037,471],{"class":470},[449,1039,475],{"class":474},[449,1041,478],{"class":474},[449,1043,481],{"class":474},[449,1045,484],{"class":474},[449,1047,487],{"class":474},[449,1049,490],{"class":474},[536,1051,1052,1062],{},[539,1053,1054],{},[542,1055,1056,1059],{},[545,1057,1058],{},"Maßnahme",[545,1060,1061],{},"Erwartetes Ergebnis",[552,1063,1064,1081],{},[542,1065,1066,1069],{},[557,1067,1068],{},"Web-Dienste entfernt",[557,1070,593,1071,1073,1074,1077,1078],{},[370,1072,596],{},", ",[370,1075,1076],{},"InstallState"," steht auf ",[370,1079,1080],{},"Available",[542,1082,1083,1086],{},[557,1084,1085],{},"Endpunkt gehärtet",[557,1087,1088,1089,1092,1093,1095,1096,1098,1099,1073,1101,1103],{},"über HTTP ",[370,1090,1091],{},"403"," statt ",[370,1094,561],{},"; im IIS-Manager steht Extended Protection auf „Required\" und „Require SSL\" ist gesetzt (",[370,1097,739],{},": ",[370,1100,700],{},[370,1102,726],{},")",[366,1105,1106,1107,1110],{},"Danach von einem Domänen-Client ",[370,1108,1109],{},"https:\u002F\u002Fsrv01.contoso.local\u002Fcertsrv"," im Browser öffnen – die Anmeldung muss weiter funktionieren. Nutzt du Defender for Identity, verschwindet der Endpunkt aus der Empfehlung aus Schritt 1.",[1112,1113,1114],"style",{},"html .light .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-light);background: var(--shiki-light-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-light-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-light-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-light-text-decoration);}html.light .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-light);background: var(--shiki-light-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-light-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-light-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-light-text-decoration);}html .default .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-default);background: var(--shiki-default-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-default-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-default-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-default-text-decoration);}html .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-default);background: var(--shiki-default-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-default-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-default-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-default-text-decoration);}html .dark .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-dark);background: var(--shiki-dark-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-dark-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-dark-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-dark-text-decoration);}html.dark .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-dark);background: var(--shiki-dark-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-dark-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-dark-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-dark-text-decoration);}html pre.shiki code .sBMFI, html code.shiki .sBMFI{--shiki-light:#E2931D;--shiki-default:#FFCB6B;--shiki-dark:#FFCB6B}html pre.shiki code .sfazB, html code.shiki .sfazB{--shiki-light:#91B859;--shiki-default:#C3E88D;--shiki-dark:#C3E88D}",{"title":445,"searchDepth":452,"depth":493,"links":1116},[1117,1118,1119,1120],{"id":363,"depth":493,"text":364},{"id":383,"depth":493,"text":384},{"id":406,"depth":493,"text":407},{"id":428,"depth":493,"text":429,"children":1121},[1122,1123,1124,1125,1126],{"id":433,"depth":764,"text":434},{"id":773,"depth":764,"text":774},{"id":834,"depth":764,"text":835},{"id":865,"depth":764,"text":866},{"id":1024,"depth":764,"text":1025},"NTLM-Relay auf die Web-Enrollment-Endpunkte von AD CS – HTTP-Endpunkte entfernen oder mit EPA und HTTPS absichern.","md",null,{},{"icon":137},{"title":134,"description":1127},"Vtr_DFmcSanCtdghPcIjOa-xyWLV_u19JFapWMWJhKQ",[1135,1137],{"title":129,"path":130,"stem":131,"description":1136,"icon":132,"children":-1},"Verwaltungsrechte auf der CA für nicht privilegierte Konten – Manage CA und Manage Certificates auf PKI-Admins beschränken.",{"title":139,"path":140,"stem":141,"description":1138,"icon":142,"children":-1},"Vorlagen ohne SID-Extension – sicherstellen, dass Zertifikate fest an das beantragende Konto gebunden sind.",1795021434769]