[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":935},["ShallowReactive",2],{"navigation":3,"\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc12":355,"\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc12-surround":930},[4,252,348],{"title":5,"path":6,"stem":7,"children":8,"icon":11},"Active Directory","\u002Factive-directory","1.active-directory\u002F1.index",[9,12,48,58,93,163,203,232],{"title":10,"path":6,"stem":7,"icon":11},"Übersicht","i-lucide-network",{"title":13,"path":14,"stem":15,"children":16,"page":47},"Privileged Accounts","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts",[17,22,27,32,37,42],{"title":18,"path":19,"stem":20,"icon":21},"Protected Users","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Fprotected-users","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F2.protected-users","i-lucide-shield-user",{"title":23,"path":24,"stem":25,"icon":26},"Not Delegated","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Faccount-not-delegated","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F3.account-not-delegated","i-lucide-user-lock",{"title":28,"path":29,"stem":30,"icon":31},"gMSA","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Fgmsa","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F4.gmsa","i-lucide-server-cog",{"title":33,"path":34,"stem":35,"icon":36},"Tier-0-Gruppen","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Fprivileged-groups","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F5.privileged-groups","i-lucide-crown",{"title":38,"path":39,"stem":40,"icon":41},"Operator-Gruppen","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Foperator-groups","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F6.operator-groups","i-lucide-user-minus",{"title":43,"path":44,"stem":45,"icon":46},"Built-in Administrator","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fprivileged-accounts\u002Fbuiltin-administrator","1.active-directory\u002F2.privileged-accounts\u002F7.builtin-administrator","i-lucide-siren",false,{"title":49,"path":50,"stem":51,"children":52,"page":47},"Trusts","\u002Factive-directory\u002Ftrusts","1.active-directory\u002F3.trusts",[53],{"title":54,"path":55,"stem":56,"icon":57},"Trust-Härtung","\u002Factive-directory\u002Ftrusts\u002Ftrust-hardening","1.active-directory\u002F3.trusts\u002F2.trust-hardening","i-lucide-handshake",{"title":59,"path":60,"stem":61,"children":62,"page":47},"Domain Controllers","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers",[63,68,73,78,83,88],{"title":64,"path":65,"stem":66,"icon":67},"NTLMv1","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fntlmv1","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F2.ntlmv1","i-lucide-shield-ban",{"title":69,"path":70,"stem":71,"icon":72},"LDAP","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fldap","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F3.ldap","i-lucide-book-lock",{"title":74,"path":75,"stem":76,"icon":77},"NTLM-Einschränkungen","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fntlm-restrictions","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F4.ntlm-restrictions","i-lucide-shield-minus",{"title":79,"path":80,"stem":81,"icon":82},"SYSVOL-Replikation (FRS)","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fsysvol-frs","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F5.sysvol-frs","i-lucide-folder-sync",{"title":84,"path":85,"stem":86,"icon":87},"DNS","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fdns","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F6.dns","i-lucide-globe-lock",{"title":89,"path":90,"stem":91,"icon":92},"DCSync-Rechte","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fdomain-controllers\u002Fdcsync","1.active-directory\u002F4.domain-controllers\u002F7.dcsync","i-lucide-database-zap",{"title":94,"path":95,"stem":96,"children":97,"page":47},"Certificates (AD CS)","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates",[98,103,108,113,118,123,128,133,138,143,148,153,158],{"title":99,"path":100,"stem":101,"icon":102},"ESC1","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc1","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F01.esc1","i-lucide-user-pen",{"title":104,"path":105,"stem":106,"icon":107},"ESC2","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc2","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F02.esc2","i-lucide-asterisk",{"title":109,"path":110,"stem":111,"icon":112},"ESC3","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc3","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F03.esc3","i-lucide-stamp",{"title":114,"path":115,"stem":116,"icon":117},"ESC4","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc4","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F04.esc4","i-lucide-file-pen-line",{"title":119,"path":120,"stem":121,"icon":122},"ESC5","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc5","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F05.esc5","i-lucide-folder-key",{"title":124,"path":125,"stem":126,"icon":127},"ESC6","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc6","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F06.esc6","i-lucide-flag",{"title":129,"path":130,"stem":131,"icon":132},"ESC7","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc7","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F07.esc7","i-lucide-user-cog",{"title":134,"path":135,"stem":136,"icon":137},"ESC8","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc8","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F08.esc8","i-lucide-globe",{"title":139,"path":140,"stem":141,"icon":142},"ESC9","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc9","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F09.esc9","i-lucide-shield-off",{"title":144,"path":145,"stem":146,"icon":147},"ESC10","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc10","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F10.esc10","i-lucide-unlink",{"title":149,"path":150,"stem":151,"icon":152},"ESC11","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc11","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F11.esc11","i-lucide-cable",{"title":154,"path":155,"stem":156,"icon":157},"ESC12","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc12","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F12.esc12","i-lucide-usb",{"title":159,"path":160,"stem":161,"icon":162},"ESC13","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fcertificates\u002Fesc13","1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F13.esc13","i-lucide-tags",{"title":164,"path":165,"stem":166,"children":167,"page":47},"Kerberos","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos",[168,173,178,183,188,193,198],{"title":169,"path":170,"stem":171,"icon":172},"Kerberoasting","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Fkerberoasting","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F2.kerberoasting","i-lucide-ticket",{"title":174,"path":175,"stem":176,"icon":177},"AS-REP Roasting","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Fasrep-roasting","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F3.asrep-roasting","i-lucide-ticket-x",{"title":179,"path":180,"stem":181,"icon":182},"Unconstrained Delegation","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Funconstrained-delegation","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F4.unconstrained-delegation","i-lucide-forward",{"title":184,"path":185,"stem":186,"icon":187},"Constrained Delegation","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Fconstrained-delegation","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F5.constrained-delegation","i-lucide-route",{"title":189,"path":190,"stem":191,"icon":192},"MachineAccountQuota","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Fmachine-account-quota","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F6.machine-account-quota","i-lucide-monitor-x",{"title":194,"path":195,"stem":196,"icon":197},"RC4 & DES","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Frc4-des","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F7.rc4-des","i-lucide-lock-keyhole-open",{"title":199,"path":200,"stem":201,"icon":202},"KRBTGT","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fkerberos\u002Fkrbtgt","1.active-directory\u002F6.kerberos\u002F8.krbtgt","i-lucide-rotate-ccw-key",{"title":204,"path":205,"stem":206,"children":207,"page":47},"Permissions","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions",[208,213,217,222,227],{"title":209,"path":210,"stem":211,"icon":212},"AdminSDHolder","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions\u002Fadminsdholder","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions\u002F2.adminsdholder","i-lucide-copy-check",{"title":214,"path":215,"stem":216,"icon":36},"Objekt-Owner","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions\u002Fobject-owners","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions\u002F3.object-owners",{"title":218,"path":219,"stem":220,"icon":221},"Shadow Credentials","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions\u002Fshadow-credentials","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions\u002F4.shadow-credentials","i-lucide-fingerprint",{"title":223,"path":224,"stem":225,"icon":226},"GPO-Rechte","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions\u002Fgpo-permissions","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions\u002F5.gpo-permissions","i-lucide-file-cog",{"title":228,"path":229,"stem":230,"icon":231},"dSHeuristics","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpermissions\u002Fdsheuristics","1.active-directory\u002F7.permissions\u002F6.dsheuristics","i-lucide-sliders-horizontal",{"title":233,"path":234,"stem":235,"children":236,"page":47},"Passwords","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpasswords","1.active-directory\u002F8.passwords",[237,242,247],{"title":238,"path":239,"stem":240,"icon":241},"Passwort-Richtlinie","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpasswords\u002Fpassword-policy","1.active-directory\u002F8.passwords\u002F2.password-policy","i-lucide-rectangle-ellipsis",{"title":243,"path":244,"stem":245,"icon":246},"Passwort-Flags","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpasswords\u002Fpassword-flags","1.active-directory\u002F8.passwords\u002F3.password-flags","i-lucide-key-square",{"title":248,"path":249,"stem":250,"icon":251},"Klartext-Passwörter","\u002Factive-directory\u002Fpasswords\u002Fcleartext-passwords","1.active-directory\u002F8.passwords\u002F4.cleartext-passwords","i-lucide-scan-eye",{"title":253,"path":254,"stem":255,"children":256,"icon":258},"Infrastruktur","\u002Finfrastruktur","2.infrastruktur\u002F1.index",[257,259,270,301,327],{"title":10,"path":254,"stem":255,"icon":258},"i-lucide-server",{"title":260,"icon":261,"path":262,"stem":263,"children":264,"page":47},"TLS & SSL","i-lucide-lock","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Ftls-ssl","2.infrastruktur\u002F2.tls-ssl",[265],{"title":266,"path":267,"stem":268,"icon":269},"Client-Renegotiation","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Ftls-ssl\u002Fclient-renegotiation","2.infrastruktur\u002F2.tls-ssl\u002F1.client-renegotiation","i-lucide-refresh-cw",{"title":271,"icon":272,"path":273,"stem":274,"children":275,"page":47},"Windows","i-simple-icons-windows","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows",[276,281,286,291,296],{"title":277,"path":278,"stem":279,"icon":280},"AlwaysInstallElevated","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows\u002Falwaysinstallelevated","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows\u002F2.alwaysinstallelevated","i-lucide-package",{"title":282,"path":283,"stem":284,"icon":285},"SMB","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows\u002Fsmb","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows\u002F3.smb","i-lucide-folder-lock",{"title":287,"path":288,"stem":289,"icon":290},"WSUS","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows\u002Fwsus","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows\u002F4.wsus","i-lucide-cloud-download",{"title":292,"path":293,"stem":294,"icon":295},"LAPS","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows\u002Flaps","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows\u002F5.laps","i-lucide-user-key",{"title":297,"path":298,"stem":299,"icon":300},"Print Spooler","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fwindows\u002Fprint-spooler","2.infrastruktur\u002F3.windows\u002F6.print-spooler","i-lucide-printer-x",{"title":302,"icon":303,"path":304,"stem":305,"children":306,"page":47},"Email Security","i-lucide-mail","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Femail-security","2.infrastruktur\u002F5.email-security",[307,312,317,322],{"title":308,"path":309,"stem":310,"icon":311},"SPF","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Femail-security\u002Fspf","2.infrastruktur\u002F5.email-security\u002F2.spf","i-lucide-mail-check",{"title":313,"path":314,"stem":315,"icon":316},"DKIM","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Femail-security\u002Fdkim","2.infrastruktur\u002F5.email-security\u002F3.dkim","i-lucide-mail-badge",{"title":318,"path":319,"stem":320,"icon":321},"DMARC","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Femail-security\u002Fdmarc","2.infrastruktur\u002F5.email-security\u002F4.dmarc","i-lucide-shield-check",{"title":323,"path":324,"stem":325,"icon":326},"DNSSEC","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Femail-security\u002Fdnssec","2.infrastruktur\u002F5.email-security\u002F5.dnssec","i-lucide-key-round",{"title":328,"icon":329,"path":330,"stem":331,"children":332,"page":47},"Name Resolution","i-lucide-radio-tower","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fname-resolution","2.infrastruktur\u002F7.name-resolution",[333,338,343],{"title":334,"path":335,"stem":336,"icon":337},"LLMNR","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fname-resolution\u002Fllmnr","2.infrastruktur\u002F7.name-resolution\u002F2.llmnr","i-lucide-radio",{"title":339,"path":340,"stem":341,"icon":342},"NetBIOS","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fname-resolution\u002Fnetbios","2.infrastruktur\u002F7.name-resolution\u002F3.netbios","i-lucide-megaphone-off",{"title":344,"path":345,"stem":346,"icon":347},"mDNS","\u002Finfrastruktur\u002Fname-resolution\u002Fmdns","2.infrastruktur\u002F7.name-resolution\u002F4.mdns","i-lucide-wifi-off",{"title":349,"path":350,"stem":351,"children":352,"icon":354},"Cloud & SaaS","\u002Fcloud-saas","3.cloud-saas\u002F1.index",[353],{"title":10,"path":350,"stem":351,"icon":354},"i-lucide-cloud",{"id":356,"title":154,"body":357,"description":923,"extension":924,"links":925,"meta":926,"navigation":927,"path":155,"seo":928,"stem":156,"__hash__":929},"docs\u002F1.active-directory\u002F5.certificates\u002F12.esc12.md",{"type":358,"value":359,"toc":911},"minimark",[360,365,378,382,385,395,398,402,405,411,417,421,426,429,490,493,561,571,578,582,585,605,616,625,632,638,645,651,654,663,706,710,713,745,748,752,755,816,822,837,852,858,862,865,868,877,890,893,902,907],[361,362,364],"h2",{"id":363},"verstehen","Verstehen",[366,367,368,369,373,374,377],"p",{},"Ein Hardware Security Module (HSM) soll den privaten Schlüssel der CA so schützen, dass er das Gerät nie verlässt. Beim YubiHSM 2 spricht die CA über den YubiHSM Key Storage Provider (KSP) mit dem Gerät. Der KSP meldet sich mit einem Authentication Key am HSM an – und das Passwort dafür steht im Klartext in der Registry des CA-Servers, im Wert ",[370,371,372],"code",{},"AuthKeysetPassword"," unter ",[370,375,376],{},"HKLM\\SOFTWARE\\Yubico\\YubiHSM",". Der KSP prüft außerdem nicht, welches Konto ihn aufruft. ESC12 beschreibt die Folge: Wer eine Shell auf dem CA-Server hat, kann den Schlüssel im HSM benutzen, ohne ihn je auszulesen. Das ist keine Einstellung, die sich abschalten lässt, sondern eine Eigenschaft dieser Middleware – der Schutz muss vom Server kommen. Übersehen wird das, weil ein HSM als Garantie gilt und der Server dahinter weniger streng behandelt wird.",[361,379,381],{"id":380},"einordnen","Einordnen",[366,383,384],{},"Ohne die Absicherung genügt ein Konto mit Anmelderecht auf dem CA-Server, um mit dem CA-Schlüssel beliebige Zertifikate zu signieren.",[386,387,388,392],"ul",{},[389,390,391],"li",{},"Ein Benutzer ohne Adminrechte, der sich auf dem CA-Server anmelden darf, verknüpft das CA-Zertifikat in seinem eigenen Zertifikatsspeicher mit dem Schlüssel im HSM und signiert damit Zertifikate auf beliebige Namen",[389,393,394],{},"Diese Zertifikate tauchen weder in der CA-Datenbank noch in den Logs der CA auf und lassen sich deshalb nicht gezielt sperren",[366,396,397],{},"Wer zusätzlich das Passwort ausliest und den Connector oder einen USB-Device-Server erreicht, kann das HSM auch von einem eigenen Rechner aus ansprechen. Ein YubiHSM bleibt trotzdem sinnvoller als ein Schlüssel in Software. Entscheidend ist, dass der CA-Server wie ein Domain Controller behandelt wird: Tier 0, keine Anmeldung für andere als PKI-Admins. Lokale Administratoren können den Schlüssel immer benutzen – das gilt aber für jede CA, mit oder ohne HSM. Prüf auch bei anderen HSM-Produkten, wie sich die CA am HSM anmeldet und wo dieses Geheimnis liegt.",[361,399,401],{"id":400},"vorbereiten","Vorbereiten",[366,403,404],{},"Die Maßnahmen ändern nichts an der CA selbst, sondern daran, wer auf den Server kommt. Betroffen sind Konten und Gruppen, die sich heute lokal, per RDP oder per WinRM anmelden dürfen, ohne PKI-Admin zu sein: Monitoring- und Backup-Konten, Helpdesk, Softwareverteilung.",[406,407,408],"warning",{},[366,409,410],{},"Größtes Risiko: Nach einer fehlerhaften ACL-Änderung kann der CA-Dienst das Passwort nicht mehr lesen und signiert keine Zertifikate und Sperrlisten mehr. Sichere vorher die ACL, behalte SYSTEM und Administrators in der Liste und teste direkt danach (Schritt 4).",[412,413,414],"tip",{},[366,415,416],{},"Fang mit den Anmelderechten an, nicht mit der Registry. Wer sich gar nicht erst auf dem CA-Server anmelden kann, kommt weder an das Passwort noch an den KSP – das schließt beide Angriffswege.",[361,418,420],{"id":419},"beheben","Beheben",[422,423,425],"h3",{"id":424},"_1-aktuellen-zustand-prüfen","1. Aktuellen Zustand prüfen",[366,427,428],{},"Auf dem CA-Server in einer PowerShell mit Adminrechten. Der zweite Teil zeigt nur, ob ein Passwort hinterlegt ist, nicht das Passwort selbst:",[430,431,437],"pre",{"className":432,"code":433,"filename":434,"language":435,"meta":436,"style":436},"language-powershell shiki shiki-themes material-theme-lighter material-theme material-theme-palenight","certutil -getreg CA\\CSP\\Provider\n\n$hsm = Get-ItemProperty 'HKLM:\\SOFTWARE\\Yubico\\YubiHSM' -ErrorAction SilentlyContinue\n[pscustomobject]@{\n  ConnectorURL = $hsm.ConnectorURL\n  AuthKeysetID = $hsm.AuthKeysetID\n  PasswordInRegistry = [bool]$hsm.AuthKeysetPassword\n}\n","PowerShell","powershell","",[370,438,439,447,454,460,466,472,478,484],{"__ignoreMap":436},[440,441,444],"span",{"class":442,"line":443},"line",1,[440,445,446],{},"certutil -getreg CA\\CSP\\Provider\n",[440,448,450],{"class":442,"line":449},2,[440,451,453],{"emptyLinePlaceholder":452},true,"\n",[440,455,457],{"class":442,"line":456},3,[440,458,459],{},"$hsm = Get-ItemProperty 'HKLM:\\SOFTWARE\\Yubico\\YubiHSM' -ErrorAction SilentlyContinue\n",[440,461,463],{"class":442,"line":462},4,[440,464,465],{},"[pscustomobject]@{\n",[440,467,469],{"class":442,"line":468},5,[440,470,471],{},"  ConnectorURL = $hsm.ConnectorURL\n",[440,473,475],{"class":442,"line":474},6,[440,476,477],{},"  AuthKeysetID = $hsm.AuthKeysetID\n",[440,479,481],{"class":442,"line":480},7,[440,482,483],{},"  PasswordInRegistry = [bool]$hsm.AuthKeysetPassword\n",[440,485,487],{"class":442,"line":486},8,[440,488,489],{},"}\n",[366,491,492],{},"Mögliche Ergebnisse:",[494,495,496,509],"table",{},[497,498,499],"thead",{},[500,501,502,506],"tr",{},[503,504,505],"th",{},"Ergebnis",[503,507,508],{},"Bedeutung",[510,511,512,525,533,547],"tbody",{},[500,513,514,522],{},[515,516,517,518,521],"td",{},"Provider ist der YubiHSM Key Storage Provider, ",[370,519,520],{},"PasswordInRegistry"," True",[515,523,524],{},"ESC12 trifft zu – weiter mit Schritt 2",[500,526,527,530],{},[515,528,529],{},"anderer Provider, Registry-Schlüssel fehlt",[515,531,532],{},"kein YubiHSM – ESC12 trifft nicht zu",[500,534,535,544],{},[515,536,537,540,541],{},[370,538,539],{},"ConnectorURL"," zeigt nicht auf ",[370,542,543],{},"127.0.0.1",[515,545,546],{},"HSM hängt über das Netz am Server – Connector zusätzlich absichern",[500,548,549,558],{},[515,550,551,554,555],{},[370,552,553],{},"AuthKeysetID"," ist ",[370,556,557],{},"1",[515,559,560],{},"prüfen, ob noch der Werks-Key mit Standardpasswort aktiv ist – Yubico sieht vor, ihn bei der Einrichtung zu ersetzen und zu löschen",[366,562,563,564,567,568,570],{},"Wie offen das Passwort liegt, zeigt der Registry-Editor unter ",[370,565,566],{},"HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\\SOFTWARE\\Yubico\\YubiHSM"," – ",[370,569,372],{}," steht dort im Klartext, im Beispiel ein Testwert:",[366,572,573],{},[574,575],"img",{"alt":576,"src":577},"Registry-Editor mit dem Schlüssel YubiHSM und den Werten AuthKeysetID, AuthKeysetPassword im Klartext und ConnectorURL","\u002Fimg\u002Factive-directory\u002Fesc12-registry.png",[422,579,581],{"id":580},"_2-zugriff-auf-den-server-prüfen","2. Zugriff auf den Server prüfen",[366,583,584],{},"Wer kommt auf den Server, und wer darf den Registry-Schlüssel lesen? Die lokalen Gruppen fragst du über ihre festen SIDs ab, damit das auch auf lokalisierten Systemen funktioniert:",[430,586,588],{"className":432,"code":587,"filename":434,"language":435,"meta":436,"style":436},"Get-LocalGroupMember -SID 'S-1-5-32-544'   # Administrators\nGet-LocalGroupMember -SID 'S-1-5-32-555'   # Remote Desktop Users\nGet-LocalGroupMember -SID 'S-1-5-32-580'   # Remote Management Users\n",[370,589,590,595,600],{"__ignoreMap":436},[440,591,592],{"class":442,"line":443},[440,593,594],{},"Get-LocalGroupMember -SID 'S-1-5-32-544'   # Administrators\n",[440,596,597],{"class":442,"line":449},[440,598,599],{},"Get-LocalGroupMember -SID 'S-1-5-32-555'   # Remote Desktop Users\n",[440,601,602],{"class":442,"line":456},[440,603,604],{},"Get-LocalGroupMember -SID 'S-1-5-32-580'   # Remote Management Users\n",[366,606,607,608,611,612,615],{},"Läuft die CA auf einem Domain Controller, schlägt ",[370,609,610],{},"Get-LocalGroupMember"," fehl – dort gibt es keine lokalen Gruppen, es gelten die Builtin-Gruppen der Domäne. Die zeigt ",[370,613,614],{},"net localgroup"," auch auf einem DC:",[430,617,619],{"className":432,"code":618,"filename":434,"language":435,"meta":436,"style":436},"net localgroup Administrators\n",[370,620,621],{"__ignoreMap":436},[440,622,623],{"class":442,"line":443},[440,624,618],{},[366,626,627,628,631],{},"Die Anmelderechte zeigt die Local Security Policy (",[370,629,630],{},"secpol.msc","): „Local Policies\" → „User Rights Assignment\" → Doppelklick auf „Allow log on locally\" und „Allow log on through Remote Desktop Services\". Auf einem Domain Controller stehen dort im Standard auch Account Operators, Backup Operators, Print Operators und Server Operators – auf einem CA-Server wäre jede dieser Gruppen ein Weg zum CA-Schlüssel:",[366,633,634],{},[574,635],{"alt":636,"src":637},"Eigenschaften von „Allow log on locally\" auf einem Domain Controller mit Administrators und den Operator-Gruppen","\u002Fimg\u002Factive-directory\u002Fesc12-logon-locally.png",[366,639,640,641,644],{},"Wer den Registry-Schlüssel lesen darf, zeigt im Registry-Editor Rechtsklick auf ",[370,642,643],{},"YubiHSM"," → „Permissions\". Im Standard erbt der Schlüssel „Read\" für Users – jeder lokal angemeldete Benutzer liest damit das Passwort:",[366,646,647],{},[574,648],{"alt":649,"src":650},"Berechtigungen des Schlüssels YubiHSM mit geerbtem Leserecht für die Gruppe Users","\u002Fimg\u002Factive-directory\u002Fesc12-registry-permissions.png",[366,652,653],{},"Dieselbe Liste als Text:",[430,655,657],{"className":432,"code":656,"filename":434,"language":435,"meta":436,"style":436},"(Get-Acl 'HKLM:\\SOFTWARE\\Yubico\\YubiHSM').Access | Format-Table IdentityReference, RegistryRights, IsInherited\n",[370,658,659],{"__ignoreMap":436},[440,660,661],{"class":442,"line":443},[440,662,656],{},[494,664,665,673],{},[497,666,667],{},[500,668,669,671],{},[503,670,505],{},[503,672,508],{},[510,674,675,683,691],{},[500,676,677,680],{},[515,678,679],{},"nur PKI-Admins in den drei Gruppen und Anmelderechten",[515,681,682],{},"Server ist sauber abgegrenzt",[500,684,685,688],{},[515,686,687],{},"Domain Users, Helpdesk-, Monitoring- oder Backup-Konten",[515,689,690],{},"kritisch – jedes dieser Konten kann den CA-Schlüssel benutzen (Schritt 3)",[500,692,693,703],{},[515,694,695,698,699,702],{},[370,696,697],{},"BUILTIN\\Users"," mit ",[370,700,701],{},"ReadKey"," auf dem Registry-Schlüssel",[515,704,705],{},"Standard-Vererbung – jeder lokal angemeldete Benutzer liest das Passwort (Schritt 4)",[422,707,709],{"id":708},"_3-anmeldung-auf-pki-admins-beschränken","3. Anmeldung auf PKI-Admins beschränken",[366,711,712],{},"Alle Konten, die keine PKI-Admins sind, aus den lokalen Gruppen entfernen. Die Anmelderechte legst du in einer GPO fest, die nur für die CA-Server gilt:",[430,714,719],{"className":715,"code":716,"filename":717,"language":718,"meta":436,"style":436},"language-ini shiki shiki-themes material-theme-lighter material-theme material-theme-palenight","Computer Configuration\\Windows Settings\\Security Settings\\Local Policies\\User Rights Assignment\n  Allow log on locally\n    = Administrators\n  Allow log on through Remote Desktop Services\n    = Administrators\n","GPO","ini",[370,720,721,726,731,736,741],{"__ignoreMap":436},[440,722,723],{"class":442,"line":443},[440,724,725],{},"Computer Configuration\\Windows Settings\\Security Settings\\Local Policies\\User Rights Assignment\n",[440,727,728],{"class":442,"line":449},[440,729,730],{},"  Allow log on locally\n",[440,732,733],{"class":442,"line":456},[440,734,735],{},"    = Administrators\n",[440,737,738],{"class":442,"line":462},[440,739,740],{},"  Allow log on through Remote Desktop Services\n",[440,742,743],{"class":442,"line":468},[440,744,735],{},[366,746,747],{},"Monitoring und Backup brauchen keine interaktive Anmeldung. Stell sie auf agentenbasierte Verfahren um oder gib ihnen ein eigenes, eng berechtigtes Konto ohne Anmelderecht.",[422,749,751],{"id":750},"_4-registry-schlüssel-absichern","4. Registry-Schlüssel absichern",[366,753,754],{},"Als zweite Schicht den Lesezugriff auf SYSTEM und Administrators begrenzen. Der CA-Dienst läuft als SYSTEM und kommt weiter an das Passwort:",[430,756,758],{"className":432,"code":757,"filename":434,"language":435,"meta":436,"style":436},"$path = 'HKLM:\\SOFTWARE\\Yubico\\YubiHSM'\n(Get-Acl $path).Sddl | Out-File C:\\Temp\\yubihsm-acl.txt\n\n$acl = Get-Acl $path\n$acl.SetAccessRuleProtection($true, $false)\nforeach ($sid in 'S-1-5-18', 'S-1-5-32-544') {\n  $rule = [System.Security.AccessControl.RegistryAccessRule]::new(\n    [System.Security.Principal.SecurityIdentifier]$sid, 'FullControl', 'ContainerInherit', 'None', 'Allow')\n  $acl.AddAccessRule($rule)\n}\nSet-Acl -Path $path -AclObject $acl\n",[370,759,760,765,770,774,779,784,789,794,799,805,810],{"__ignoreMap":436},[440,761,762],{"class":442,"line":443},[440,763,764],{},"$path = 'HKLM:\\SOFTWARE\\Yubico\\YubiHSM'\n",[440,766,767],{"class":442,"line":449},[440,768,769],{},"(Get-Acl $path).Sddl | Out-File C:\\Temp\\yubihsm-acl.txt\n",[440,771,772],{"class":442,"line":456},[440,773,453],{"emptyLinePlaceholder":452},[440,775,776],{"class":442,"line":462},[440,777,778],{},"$acl = Get-Acl $path\n",[440,780,781],{"class":442,"line":468},[440,782,783],{},"$acl.SetAccessRuleProtection($true, $false)\n",[440,785,786],{"class":442,"line":474},[440,787,788],{},"foreach ($sid in 'S-1-5-18', 'S-1-5-32-544') {\n",[440,790,791],{"class":442,"line":480},[440,792,793],{},"  $rule = [System.Security.AccessControl.RegistryAccessRule]::new(\n",[440,795,796],{"class":442,"line":486},[440,797,798],{},"    [System.Security.Principal.SecurityIdentifier]$sid, 'FullControl', 'ContainerInherit', 'None', 'Allow')\n",[440,800,802],{"class":442,"line":801},9,[440,803,804],{},"  $acl.AddAccessRule($rule)\n",[440,806,808],{"class":442,"line":807},10,[440,809,489],{},[440,811,813],{"class":442,"line":812},11,[440,814,815],{},"Set-Acl -Path $path -AclObject $acl\n",[366,817,818,821],{},[370,819,820],{},"SetAccessRuleProtection"," schaltet die Vererbung ab und verwirft die geerbten Einträge. Im Registry-Editor entspricht das „Permissions\" → „Advanced\" → „Disable inheritance\" → „Remove all inherited permissions from this object\" und danach „Add\" für SYSTEM und Administrators mit Full Control – das Skript sichert aber vorher die alte ACL. Direkt danach prüfen, dass die CA weiter signieren kann:",[430,823,825],{"className":432,"code":824,"filename":434,"language":435,"meta":436,"style":436},"Restart-Service -Name CertSvc\ncertutil -CRL\n",[370,826,827,832],{"__ignoreMap":436},[440,828,829],{"class":442,"line":443},[440,830,831],{},"Restart-Service -Name CertSvc\n",[440,833,834],{"class":442,"line":449},[440,835,836],{},"certutil -CRL\n",[366,838,839,840,843,844,847,848,851],{},"Erwartet wird ",[370,841,842],{},"CertUtil: -CRL command completed successfully."," Schlägt der Befehl fehl, spiel die gesicherte ACL zurück: ",[370,845,846],{},"$acl.SetSecurityDescriptorSddlForm((Get-Content C:\\Temp\\yubihsm-acl.txt))",", dann erneut ",[370,849,850],{},"Set-Acl",".",[853,854,855],"note",{},[366,856,857],{},"Hatten fremde Konten Zugriff auf den Server, ersetze den Authentication Key im HSM durch einen neuen und trag das neue Passwort in der Registry ein. Ob mit dem CA-Schlüssel bereits Zertifikate signiert wurden, lässt sich aus der CA nicht nachvollziehen – bei konkretem Verdacht bleibt nur, das CA-Zertifikat mit neuem Schlüssel zu erneuern.",[422,859,861],{"id":860},"_5-verifizieren","5. Verifizieren",[366,863,864],{},"Die Prüfungen aus Schritt 2 wiederholen. In den Gruppen und Anmelderechten stehen nur noch PKI-Admins. Unter „Permissions\" des Registry-Schlüssels stehen nur noch SYSTEM und Administrators, beide nicht geerbt – Users fehlt.",[366,866,867],{},"Der Connector darf nur lokal lauschen. Der Standardport ist 12345:",[430,869,871],{"className":432,"code":870,"filename":434,"language":435,"meta":436,"style":436},"Get-NetTCPConnection -State Listen -LocalPort 12345 | Select-Object LocalAddress, LocalPort\n",[370,872,873],{"__ignoreMap":436},[440,874,875],{"class":442,"line":443},[440,876,870],{},[366,878,839,879,881,882,885,886,889],{},[370,880,543],{},". Steht dort ",[370,883,884],{},"0.0.0.0"," oder eine Netzadresse, ist das HSM aus dem Netz ansprechbar – die Bindung in der Connector-Konfiguration (",[370,887,888],{},"yubihsm-connector.yaml",") korrigieren oder den Port per Firewall auf den CA-Server begrenzen.",[366,891,892],{},"Zum Abschluss mit einem Konto ohne Adminrechte testen, sofern es eines mit Anmelderecht geben muss:",[430,894,896],{"className":432,"code":895,"filename":434,"language":435,"meta":436,"style":436},"reg query \"HKLM\\SOFTWARE\\Yubico\\YubiHSM\"\n",[370,897,898],{"__ignoreMap":436},[440,899,900],{"class":442,"line":443},[440,901,895],{},[366,903,839,904],{},[370,905,906],{},"ERROR: Access is denied.",[908,909,910],"style",{},"html .light .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-light);background: var(--shiki-light-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-light-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-light-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-light-text-decoration);}html.light .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-light);background: var(--shiki-light-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-light-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-light-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-light-text-decoration);}html .default .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-default);background: var(--shiki-default-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-default-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-default-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-default-text-decoration);}html .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-default);background: var(--shiki-default-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-default-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-default-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-default-text-decoration);}html .dark .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-dark);background: var(--shiki-dark-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-dark-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-dark-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-dark-text-decoration);}html.dark .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-dark);background: var(--shiki-dark-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-dark-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-dark-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-dark-text-decoration);}",{"title":436,"searchDepth":443,"depth":449,"links":912},[913,914,915,916],{"id":363,"depth":449,"text":364},{"id":380,"depth":449,"text":381},{"id":400,"depth":449,"text":401},{"id":419,"depth":449,"text":420,"children":917},[918,919,920,921,922],{"id":424,"depth":456,"text":425},{"id":580,"depth":456,"text":581},{"id":708,"depth":456,"text":709},{"id":750,"depth":456,"text":751},{"id":860,"depth":456,"text":861},"Klartext-Passwort des YubiHSM auf dem CA-Server – Zugriff so einschränken, dass niemand den CA-Schlüssel mitbenutzen kann.","md",null,{},{"icon":157},{"title":154,"description":923},"9msQeOG5x7UNFSCdwuAOMUSng5WJzEdNi9PvUutKhHc",[931,933],{"title":149,"path":150,"stem":151,"description":932,"icon":152,"children":-1},"Unverschlüsselte Zertifikatsanträge per RPC – NTLM-Relay auf die RPC-Schnittstelle der CA unterbinden.",{"title":159,"path":160,"stem":161,"description":934,"icon":162,"children":-1},"Issuance Policy mit verknüpfter Gruppe – verhindern, dass ein Zertifikat unbemerkt Gruppenrechte verleiht.",1795021434864]